Skip to content

A Loaded Anniversary

Books and pundits tackle the Plains of Abraham, but do they go far enough?

Jack Mitchell

Northern Armageddon: the Battle of the Plains of Abraham

D. Peter MacLeod

Douglas and McIntyre

379 pages, hardcover

ISBN: 9781553654124

Québec ville assiégée, 1759–1760

Jacques Lacoursière and Hélène Quimper

Septentrion

270 pages, softcover

ISBN: 9782894485811

Wolfe and Montcalm: Their Lives, Their Times and the Fate of a Continent

Joy Carroll

Firefly Books

296 pages, softcover

ISBN: 9781552979051

Les plaines d’Abraham: L’adieu à la Nouvelle-France?

Gérard Saint-Martin

Economica

277 pages, softcover

ISBN: 9782717853506

Quebec: the Story of three Sieges

Stephen Manning

McGill-Queen’s University Press

256 pages, hardcover

ISBN: 9780773536395

What vexes me most, however, is the reflection that Arthur Wellington will be as immortal as Napoleon Bonaparte. Has not the name of Pontius Pilate in a similar way become as unforgettable as that of Christ? Wellington and Napoleon! It is a wonderful phenomenon that the human mind can think of both at the same time.

Thus Heinrich Heine, poet and Bonapartist, writing in 1828, on the caprice of History. Events had lent an epic lustre to Waterloo, elevating Wellington to Homeric status, where sober analysis should (he felt) have canonized the emperor only. Still, as Canadians could tell him, both the heroes of 1815 missed a trick, for both survived the battle. One can only wonder what history would have done with a Wellington slain in his hour of triumph, or with a Napoleon overthrown only because Fate, in the form of a cannonball, had intervened.

Jack Mitchell is a poet and novelist. His latest book is D, or 500 Aphorisms, Maxims, & Reflections (2017).  He is an associate professor of classics at Dalhousie University.

Advertisement

Advertisement