Ruth Roach Pierson taught women’s history, feminist and post-colonial studies at the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education/University of Toronto from 1980 to 2001, and European and women’s history at Memorial University of Newfoundland from 1970 to 1980. Since retiring she has published three poetry collections: Where No Window Was (BuschekBooks, 2002), Aide-Mémoire (BuschekBooks, 2007), which was a finalist for the Governor General’s Award in 2008, and Contrary (Tightrope Books, 2011). A fourth, Realignment, will appear from Palimpsest Press in 2015. She is the editor of the anthology of film poems I Found It at the Movies (Guernica Editions, 2014).
Related Letters and Responses
Marc AllainChelsea, Quebec
There is a disappointing irony in having Jeffrey Simpson, a journalist and exemplary Ottawa insider, review Jody Wilson-Raybould’s memoir of her time as an outsider in Justin Trudeau’s cabinet — especially since she points to the failings of our media and the overriding cynicism of journalists as contributing to the lack of independent oversight of the conduct of our government.
Whatever one thinks of “Indian” in the Cabinet and its author, Wilson-Raybould’s actions were highly unusual in the history of our Parliament. So rarely do ministers dissent publicly on the basis of principles; only Warren Allmand comes to mind. He was a minister in another Trudeau’s cabinet, who twice paid a price for standing firm on principles. But even Allmand did not suggest that the “first among equals” and his office were treading quite close to obstructing justice.
Our system of democracy really could use more who are like Wilson-Raybould, Jane Philpott, and Warren Allmand — inside cabinet and out.
Garfield EmersonToronto
Jeffrey Simpson’s scoffing attack against Jody Wilson-Raybould was unfair. His view of realpolitik prejudicially characterized her as a rookie MP who lacked the proper masculine Anglo-Saxon experiences to hold the office of attorney general and who displayed “startling naïveté mixed with a powerful sense of personal virtue.”
Too long in Ottawa, Simpson has become immune to basic ethical norms and common-law conventions, which are fundamental to our freedom and liberty. Wilson-Raybould defended our common-law rights with integrity. Simpson misspoke that Wilson-Raybould “decided she had no discretion to countermand the intention of the director to prosecute” SNC‑Lavalin. She knew the attorney general had prosecutorial discretion. Contrary to Justin Trudeau’s direct pressures, and those from the disgraced finance minister Bill Morneau and their hired hands, Wilson-Raybould administered justice impartially and independently, free of partisan political pressures. Trudeau was held in violation of the Conflict of Interest Act for attempting to coerce Wilson-Raybould to reverse the independent decision of the director to prosecute SNC-Lavalin.
Wilson-Raybould was ethically right to record the cold Machiavellian call from Trudeau’s consigliere Michael Wernick. The transcript is a harrowing testimony of a secret attempt to subvert the democratic norm of the independent and impartial administration of justice. Wilson-Raybould upheld the rule of law with the will of a Margaret Thatcher: “The lady’s not for turning.”
@ChristineRyan9via Twitter
This was fascinating. In hindsight it seems the “perfect storm” of Fanboy and Princess personalities of the main characters may have been the demise of the promise of JT. The effects have lasted. Protagonist JWR, too rigid for success, starts fires in revenge.
@TheHerleBurlyvia Twitter
How delightful to find long-form Jeff Simpson, insightful as ever.