Generative artificial intelligence is causing trouble for short stories. Crafting them has long been important to fiction writers’ development, allowing beginners to hone their art whether or not they move on to writing novels. Now the tyros must wonder: Why put in the hours necessary to gain expertise when you can simply prompt a chatbot to spit out potential prizewinners — especially when plenty of other people are availing themselves of this easy out?
The situation isn’t hypothetical. Publishers have been flooded with AI-authored submissions. Literary laureates are being accused of covertly resorting to AI assistance. Whether you’re an acquisitions editor, creative writing instructor, or lay reader, every new piece of writing you encounter demands that you put it through some version of a Turing test to gauge whether it’s authentically human-made. Unfortunately, even the experts are turning out to be bad at such evaluations. Bot-wrought material is in the...
Robert McGill is the author of the short fiction collection Simple Creatures, a finalist for the 2025 Atwood Gibson Writers’ Trust Fiction Prize. His most recent novel is A Suitable Companion for the End of Your Life.