Skip to content

From the archives

Behind the Lines

Two depictions of the Great War

Quite the Catch

Nicholas Herring’s debut

Peggy Who

The long-awaited memoir

The Quiet Revolutionary

An overshadowed premier

Graham Fraser

Jean Lesage: Bâtisseur du Québec moderne

Jocelyn Saint-Pierre

Septentrion

696 pages, softcover and ebook

Jean Lesage, as his biographer puts it, was a builder of modern Quebec. Premier between 1960 and 1966, he led an extraordinary team that dragged the province into modernity. Hardly forgotten, he has nonetheless not received the attention he deserves. While there is a bookshelf of biographies of René Lévesque, there have been few of Lesage. Quebec City’s airport is named after him — which once prompted someone to ask his son, “Aside from running an airport, what did your father do?”

Lesage was a handsome man and not a little vain, but he worked incredibly hard. He would phone Lévesque early in the morning, when his minister, a night owl, was still asleep. Eventually Lévesque told the hotel where he was staying that there was some crank claiming to be Jean Lesage who kept calling him, and he asked that the switchboard not put him through. Despite this tiff and the tensions that ensued when Lévesque paid little attention to cabinet solidarity and pushed a progressive agenda in public, Lévesque was a huge admirer of Lesage and his work ethic. So was Jacques Parizeau, who had been one of his senior advisers. “Mr. Lesage taught us how to work,” he said. “Terribly demanding of himself, he was just as demanding of others, rigorous, knowing the files in prodigious fashion, demanding of everyone around him that they know them as well, he taught us that we could, in fact, make the state of Quebec something serious, efficient, and great all at once.”

Born in Montreal in modest circumstances in 1912, Lesage moved to Quebec City with his family in 1921. There his father worked for an insurance company. Jean attended classical college and then studied law at Université Laval, graduating in 1934 and finishing near the top of his class while being involved in debates, in theatre, and in the army reserve. His uncle, Joseph-Arthur Lesage, was an active Liberal named to the Senate and a good friend of Chubby Power, a mainstay of the Liberal Party who was later brought into cabinet by Mackenzie King. These men provided Jean with his first taste of political activity and were critical sponsors when he decided to run for office.

For a decade, Lesage practised law in Quebec City, representing lumberjacks, farmers, and an insurance company. He also invested in a Gaspé telephone company. During the Second World War, he was a lawyer for the federal Wartime Prices and Trade Board and a provincial prosecutor. He opposed conscription, campaigning for the No side in the 1942 referendum on the issue.

In 1945, the moment was right for him to enter politics. On his uncle’s advice, he ran in the federal election and was elected as the MP for Montmagny-L’Islet. In Ottawa, he was among the Quebec MPs known as Little Chicago: a hard-drinking group who lobbied for better French-language services, the appointment of French Canadians, then under-represented in the federal government, and greater Canadian autonomy internationally.

In 1951, Lesage became parliamentary secretary to Lester Pearson, then secretary of state for external affairs. Increasingly, he was involved in foreign policy, representing Canada at a United Nations conference and participating in eight international missions. In 1952, he was named parliamentary secretary to Douglas Abbott, the finance minister. In 1953, he became minister of northern affairs and national resources, a post he held until the Liberals were defeated in 1957, travelling the Arctic and “safeguarding” the health of its inhabitants.

Lesage then became the Quebec Liberal leader and steered the party to power in 1960, managing cabinet superstars like Lévesque, Paul Gérin-Lajoie (who created the education department), and Eric Kierans, as well as public servants like Parizeau, Claude Morin, and Michel Bélanger, who all pushed him farther and faster than he originally wanted to go in putting the revolution in Quebec’s Quiet Revolution.

Ultimately, the changes went too far and too fast, and the Liberals were defeated in 1966. Lesage resumed his legal career, joining numerous boards of directors and reappearing in the public eye as a passionate voice for Canada during the 1980 referendum, shortly before he died at the age of sixty-eight.

Jocelyn Saint-Pierre worked in the library of the Assemblée nationale and in the reconstruction of debates before the introduction of Hansard. Not surprisingly, this position gave him access to small-town newspapers, graduate theses, and the dozens of books about the Quiet Revolution. His admiration for Lesage in his prime is without limits. Lesage’s speech as the newly chosen Liberal leader was “magnificent, stimulating, pronounced with eloquence and energy.” As a television performer, he succeeded “brilliantly.” As premier, he served with “honour abroad,” delivering a “memorable” address in Paris on one occasion.

Saint-Pierre’s sympathy for Quebec independence is clear. He argues that Gérin-Lajoie and Lévesque “should have had the courage” that François Aquin demonstrated when he left the Liberal Party and declared his support for Quebec independence after Charles de Gaulle’s “Vive le Québec libre” speech in 1967. And he believes that young people were not wrong to see their province as “a colony within the Canadian federation.”

However, Saint-Pierre’s knowledge and understanding of English-speaking Canada is, to say the least, limited. Jean Lesage: Bâtisseur du Québec moderne includes numerous spelling mistakes of English names and terms. “Loose cannon” becomes “loose canon,” for example. Peter Cowan is presented as Peter Cohen, while Gordon Pape becomes Gordon Page. There are three different spellings for Maclean’s.

These are trivial errors compared with Saint-Pierre’s misunderstanding of Canada’s political and constitutional reality. In the 1940s and ’50s, Ottawa resisted pressure from Quebec to establish diplomatic relations with the Vatican. Saint-Pierre has a simple explanation: “At the time, Canada does not yet have a representative at the Vatican because it is still a British colony; it is a minister of the British Foreign Office who plays this role.” Wrong. Canada stopped being a British colony in 1931 with the Statute of Westminster. Canada did not have an ambassador to the Vatican until 1969 because of deep-rooted political opposition from Protestant and anti-Catholic parts of the country. The real reason isn’t pretty — but it bears no resemblance to Saint-Pierre’s explanation.

Similarly, Saint-Pierre explains the cool reaction Lesage received when he went on a speaking tour in western Canada in 1965: “The anglophones of the West displayed their astonishment at the stubbornness of francophones who did not want to assimilate.” That’s a simplistic interpretation of his failure to convince audiences of the merits of special status for Quebec. One of the fourteen reporters who followed him on that trip wrote that the premier encountered a “dense fog of unawareness.”

Saint-Pierre’s book is an extremely detailed account of the rise and fall of Lesage’s political career. It is unfortunate that it is marred by the author’s lack of knowledge or understanding of English-speaking Canada. Jean Lesage deserved better.

Graham Fraser has written numerous books, including René Lévesque and the Parti Québécois in Power and Playing for Keeps: The Making of the Prime Minister, 1988.

Advertisement

Advertisement