In 1963, I went to Duke University in Durham, North Carolina, for doctoral studies in history. I was a lieutenant in the Canadian Army on leave without pay, and I arrived with my heavily pregnant wife and young daughter in tow. When I presented myself to the registrar’s office, I was handed a form requiring me to register for the draft, one that all foreign students had to complete. I could not do this, I told the clerk, because I was an officer in an allied military. We argued back and forth for a few minutes, and he conceded that I was likely right. I did not register and thus escaped becoming, as the subtitle of this book puts it, a Canadian transnational fighter.
Many Canadians have willingly volunteered to serve in other people’s wars. The list of conflicts includes the American Civil War, the papal struggle against Giuseppe Garibaldi’s campaign to unite Italy, the Spanish Civil War, the Chinese Civil War, the Arab-Israeli War of 1948, the Vietnam War, the ISIS wars in the Middle East, and the Ukrainian resistance to the Russian invasion that still continues. Most have been soldiers, a few nurses, and all have gone off to do battle for causes they believed in. Wars of Conviction: A History of Canadian Transnational Fighters, the product of a conference at York University in 2024, organized by the editors, is the first to bring together some of their stories and the subsequent work to memorialize them.
The book includes a global overview of the estimated quarter-million foreign fighters since the nineteenth century by the American scholar David Malet. Another chapter, by Tyler Wentzell, a lawyer, historian, and soldier, examines governmental efforts to control volunteering in foreign wars. Legislation that applied in British North America in the nineteenth century tried to forbid service in other militaries and banned recruiting for them in the empire. In Canada, the Foreign Enlistment Act of 1937 was put in place in an attempt to prevent volunteers from taking up arms in the Spanish Civil War. Ottawa’s legislation proved to be no more successful than Britain’s had been. “It was ineffectively applied,” Wentzell writes. “At best, it is a vestigial statute of no modern relevance. At worst, it is an example of the inconsistent application of an overly vague and largely unenforceable criminal law.” Why unenforceable? Because the government is pragmatic, recognizing that in some instances — Spain, Israel, and Ukraine, for example —“foreign fighters have become celebrated folk heroes, whether their service was legal or not.”
Earlier conflicts illustrate the problem. Large numbers of Canadians went south to enlist in the Union Army during the American Civil War, and there were effectively no official measures to stop them. Many fewer apparently went further south to join the Confederate army, but almost no records exist of these volunteers. Several years later, some 500 francophones volunteered to serve as Pontifical Zouaves in response to a very public recruiting drive organized by prominent citizens in Quebec. Ottawa made no attempt to interfere. A letter printed in the English-language Montreal Witness tartly observed that the Crown had shown either “a culpable ignorance of the law, or a thorough contempt for its provisions.” John A. Macdonald’s government apparently saw little point in trying to enforce a statute that would only alienate much of Catholic Quebec so soon after Confederation.
The Spanish Civil War in the late 1930s was divisive in Canada, hence the 1937 legislation. Quebec Catholics supported Francisco Franco’s forces and objected to the anti-Catholic violence of the republic’s military, as well as to the Canadian Communist Party’s recruiting campaign. But if some 1,700 Canadians — three-quarters of them party members and a similar portion immigrants, as the Canadian War Museum’s Michael Petrou points out — went to Spain, none of those who volunteered and none who returned home ever faced trial. The RCMP, however, considered them all dangerous Communists and kept track of them for years. That didn’t stop the volunteers from carving out a place in the public memory as defenders of democracy, even if they were never able to persuade Ottawa to grant them veterans’ benefits.
Nor was there any effort to stop the 300 or so Canadians who went to fight for the new state of Israel in 1948, some former RCAF pilots among them receiving good pay, or the 20,000 to 30,000 who joined the U.S. military in the Vietnam War. And when Volodymyr Zelensky issued a call for volunteers to assist Ukraine’s fight against Russia in 2022, there was no objection from Ottawa. That February, the foreign minister, Melanie Joly, stated, “Let me be clear: we are all very supportive of any form of support to Ukrainians right now.”
Money and a desire for adventure have motivated volunteers, but so have religion, ethnicity, idealism, and ideology. Legislation has not been successful in dealing with such motivations, not least when Ottawa has encouraged volunteers. But the Canadian government did become concerned when some Canadians journeyed to the Middle East to support ISIS in its violent attempts to create a caliphate in the first two decades of the twenty-first century. Some were volunteers joining the Kurds against ISIS, as Petrou notes, and these were idealists.
As a Public Safety Canada report stated in 2018, at least ninety-five Canadians were then fighting with ISIS or other terrorist organizations, and sixty more had already returned to Canada. Amarnath Amarasingam, of Queen’s University, and Morgan Fox, of the University of Toronto, detail who these young Muslim fighters were, why they left Canada, and why Canadians should be concerned about those who have returned. Since 2023, the government has been repatriating its citizens, especially women and children. Some of the women have been charged. Male fighters are also entitled under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms to return, but like their spouses can be referred to a “countering violent extremism” program. We must hope this is sufficient.
Is it time for Ottawa to draft new legislation to prevent Canadians from heading off to other people’s wars? Wentzell has some suggestions on ways to punish bad state actors, and his overarching point seems inescapable: the Foreign Enlistment Act is outdated and best suited for the dustbin.
Tim Cook, one of the editors of this volume as well as the author of one of its chapters, died in October 2025. His editorial colleagues include tributes to him in this book. I should add my own. I worked with Tim on a Canadian War Museum exhibition on the role of the Canadian Corps in the Hundred Days campaign of 1918, which played a major part in Germany’s defeat, and we ran a conference together in 2019 on the events that followed the end of the First World War and co-edited a subsequent book, Canada 1919: A Nation Shaped by War. Tim was a delight to work with, cooperative, efficient, always cheerful, and an enormously productive scholar. His death is a great loss to Canadian historical research and writing. He was a good friend, and I mourn him.
J.L. Granatstein writes on Canadian political and military history. His many books include Canada’s Army: Waging War and Keeping the Peace.