Skip to content

From the archives

Behind the Lines

Two depictions of the Great War

Quite the Catch

Nicholas Herring’s debut

Peggy Who

The long-awaited memoir

Evasive Manoeuvres

Patrick deWitt walks a tightrope

Tom Jokinen

Dodge City

Patrick deWitt

House of Anansi Press

240 pages, hardcover and ebook

In 2023, Patrick deWitt did one of those New York Times Q & As about the books on his nightstand, how he organizes his library, what he likes that no one’s heard of. This last was the one that caught me: it was William Hoffman Jr.’s The Loser, from 1968, a memoir of a gambling addiction. DeWitt picked it up not for its content but “based on its incredible cover.” The dust jacket of The Loser (which shares a title with a German novel by Thomas Bernhard, which we’ll get to) is minimalist. It’s a monochrome picture, presumably of Hoffman, obscured by the title and his own name in block letters; one eye peers between the “L” and the “O,” without expression. It’s haunting if you want it to be, doubly haunting if you imagine that the author didn’t intend it to be haunting. The book, deWitt reveals, is about gambling, but with a dark subtext climbing out of the text: this man, despite what he claims, is still addicted.

Patrick deWitt’s own novels have similar subtexts: something dark and painful is in there. But they are deliberate and tightly controlled, disguised by an elegant ease of style that’s usually called deadpan: quietly funny, clinical when necessary, with characters either overexplaining or underexplaining their grim situations (which we’ll also get to). But back to Hoffman’s The Loser. This answer caught me because I also buy books for the covers, despite the old adage that advises not to. And then I saw the cover of deWitt’s Dodge City and wanted to read it because the picture on the front is the same picture that’s on the front of the NYRB Classics edition of Short Letter, Long Farewell, by the Nobel laureate Peter Handke.

The picture is of a hotel room in the 1970s. Someone’s on the bed, but we can see only their legs, in jeans and low-top Converse Chuck Taylors. A TV bolted to the wall is on, but the screen is bleached out by the light coming through the window — not a pleasant light. The image is by Stephen Shore, who took heat, early in his career, for taking pictures without obvious subjects. It is deadpan: sad and funny and familiar, but mostly sad, because something about the room feels desperate.

An illustration by Blair Kelly for Tom Jokinen’s December 2026 review of “Dodge City,” by Patrick deWitt.

Bumping into geopolitics and family drama on his way to cross the border.

Blair Kelly

The same goes for Short Letter, Long Farewell, about a German man following his ex-wife across America, or rather she’s following him. Both are true. The point is they’re each lost, emotionally, until they meet up, somehow, with the film director John Ford, who explains America to them: “We talk about everything, so there’s nothing left to dream about.”

In Dodge City, Lee Clarke embarks on a cross-country road trip, not because he wants to but because he has received a short letter from the United States government. We’re in California, Lyndon B. Johnson is president, there’s war in Vietnam. Lee is expelled from college for punching a boastful loser at a party. The letter is his draft notice. It lights the ignition on the story: he decides to escape to Canada rather than fight and likely die a world away. What ensues is the long farewell, first with his girlfriend, Cal, whom he may or may not be in love with, and vice versa. “Lee didn’t speak unless there was something to say,” we’re told. That’s true enough for both of them:

He said, “When do you want me to stop pretending?”
“Pretending what?”
“That I’m your boyfriend.”
She turned to look at him. “Whenever you want.”
“And what if I don’t want to stop?”
“Then don’t.”

And so on. Cal can’t imagine talking with Lee about his escape to Canada or going with him either, so she leaves him a note, stuck to the door with bubble gum: “I love you basically but I can’t do it and I’m sorry, seriously.” Conversations in deWitt books ring true because no one says what they really think, except sometimes in notes, and the truth requires effortful teasing out by the reader, as it does in the fiction of Ivy Compton-Burnett, another master of the deadpan.

Lee sells his car for cash and arranges to take another man’s Jaguar from the West Coast to the East Coast as a driver for hire. The rest of the long farewell is a classic quest, or pilgrimage, to square things with his family before he ends up in Toronto, Vancouver, or Montreal: destination and destiny are unclear, although deWitt hints that fate is always inarticulate and vague. We all must act on little or no information, and destiny is that which emerges only in hindsight. Is Lee doing the right thing, dodging the draft? Is that his destiny or is he escaping it?

The question comes up or rather hangs over conversations as he and the Jaguar follow a path from hotel to hotel (maybe even the kind with bolted-down TVs) to see his father, now the reluctant dog catcher in their hometown of Concrete, Washington, and his divorced mother, who lives with her brother Wallace, in Billings, Montana. The set piece with mother and uncle, both of whom are (of course) emotionally scarred but not without wisdom, is worth reading more than once. They are like the French family in the extended version of Apocalypse Now that Captain Willard happens upon in the jungle: strained elegance in the middle of a nightmare. They banter in a kind of mid-Atlantic screwball George-and-Martha dialogue — Ben Hecht meets Tennessee Williams — which can’t hide the warmth deWitt (like the reader) feels for them. They’re fully human, and odd, and, again, familiar. You know these people:

“No, the heart mimics only the darker stories,” answered Uncle Wallace.
Lee’s mother said, “Wallace plucks theories from the clouds, but never with any evidence.”
“There’s evidence.”
“And what is it?”
“The portrait of our society at present.”
Lee’s mother scoffed. “That’s nothing better than cynicism.”
“What’s wrong with cynicism?”
“It’s a dullard’s shortcut.”
Uncle Wallace said, “Cynicism is a comfort to the user, as it brings a pleasing, meanish joy.” He lifted his fork and took a bite of the meat loaf. “Excellent.”

Patrick deWitt is not a cynic. His comedy is deadpan. Here’s the difference: David Letterman and Bill Murray both use irony for comic effect. Letterman is a cynic, in that he is sure it’s all going to hell. Murray, especially in films by Wes Anderson, is deadpan: there’s infinite hope, if not, as Kafka said, for you and for me. A young Bill Murray, say from Stripes or better yet the underrated The Razor’s Edge, would be a convincing Lee Clarke. Donald Glover would be even better, even though he’s now forty-three and well past draft age.

DeWitt’s novels can feel like film treatments, heavy as they are on elusive dialogue, and his The Sisters Brothers was adapted as a good neo-Western with John C. Reilly and Joaquin Phoenix (the book is better). Kelly Reichardt, who makes slow, deadpan pictures like Showing Up, starring Michelle Williams, could direct Dodge City, and in fact she optioned deWitt’s Undermajordomo Minor, from 2015, but that project is on hold.

Which is not to say that Dodge City is a pop culture artifact. It’s literature in the vein of Charles Portis and Joy Williams or Thomas Bernhard of The Loser, all of whom walk the deadpan tightrope: it’s dangerous up there. Humour is hard. Some slapstick is okay (as Buster Keaton, who invented deadpan, knew), but puns are out. Detail is what makes it work. When Lee visits Harry, his estranged brother in Duluth, Minnesota, both agree to flavour their awkward reunion with beer and Lee’s amphetamines, which are meant to keep him alert on the journey. The inevitable hangover follows. In the morning, Harry can’t touch his raisin bran. “I can’t eat this,” he says. Lee has no such problem and doles out the pills, one each. Harry takes his with water. Lee takes his with the last of the milk in his cereal bowl. 

A lesser writer than deWitt would not have included that cinematic detail. Don’t ask me why it’s funny, but it is. It’s also human and weirdly endearing.

Tom Jokinen lives and writes in Winnipeg.

Advertisement

Advertisement