It is dusk on a remote stretch of highway in the California desert. As the heat rises and the shadows lengthen, two muscle cars face each other, their engines roaring. At a signal, the drivers, blond, tanned young men wearing dark sunglasses and brave grins, explode their cars from their starting points and race head-long toward each other. Dust rises; the scattered spectators hold their breath. Perhaps good sense will prevail and both drivers will swerve before impact; perhaps one will swerve and suffer the humiliation of defeat; perhaps both will die.
This is, of course, chicken, one of many scenarios used to illustrate and predict human behaviour in the science of game theory, a field pioneered by mathematical giants such as John von Neumann and John Nash (of the book and movie A Beautiful Mind). Game theorists specify a scenario or “game” and attach a payoff for each player to each of the possible outcomes. If the players act rationally, each will select the strategy that provides the greatest personal payoff. This modelling technique has been applied to everything from nuclear proliferation to grocery shopping and can provide useful, if occasionally pessimistic, insights about human behaviour.
The prisoner’s dilemma, for example, is a game theory classic. In this scenario, the police interview two burglars in separate rooms and press them to rat on each other. If only one cooperates, he goes free while the other gets an eight-year sentence; if both keep quiet, they each receive a lesser three-year term; and if they both betray each other, each gets five years. The dilemma for each prisoner is whether to rat on his comrade; the paradox is that they do, and both go to jail for five years. By acting in their individual interests, they achieve the worst possible collective result.
In No One Makes You Shop at Wal-Mart: The Surprising Deceptions of Individual Choice, game theory is the basis of Tom Slee’s argument that individual choice is not all it’s cracked up to be. He describes free-market economies as driven by “Marketthink,” a mindset that worships unrestricted individual choice. For Slee, however, game theoretic scenarios like the prisoner’s dilemma demonstrate that people, acting individually and rationally, make bad choices. Using Marketthink as a straw man, he argues that such games serve as an indictment of unfettered individual choice, which should therefore be restricted through “collective action,” government incentives and regulation.
To build his case, Slee makes an assertion early in the book that underpins much of what follows: that what we choose does not necessarily indicate what we prefer. He contends that we are often not happy with the consequences of our choices, such as when we shop at Wal-Mart and the neighbourhood store goes out of business.
Fair enough—but this is different from saying that choices do not indicate preferences. Within the available options, we choose the one we like best, or dislike least. We may not be satisfied with the ultimate outcome, but we made our choice according to our preference between the available alternatives. To argue, as Slee does, that we would prefer to have someone else choose for us is something of a stretch.
The idea that people make bad choices is not particularly controversial, and game theory is not really needed to make the point. People smoke although they know it will eventually kill them, and pollute the environment even though they love trees. But Slee’s agenda is to demonstrate the evils of too much choice, and game theory is his chosen method.
Although game theory provides insights about human behaviour, however, it is very sensitive to what you assume, from the basic premise that people act rationally to further assumptions about their ends. Like other games, the prisoner’s dilemma is an artificial situation: its dismal outcome only happens when the payoffs are carefully structured so that each player is better off betraying the other. But in the real world, human beings make choices based on a wide range of factors, some quantifiable, some not, some observable, some hidden, some logical, some emotional, some apparently senseless. Extrapolations from game theory to reality run the risk of oversimplification and need to be handled with care.
In Slee’s view, for example, unrestricted individual choice leads to unwanted consequences, such as the demise of the neighbourhood store. But he conveniently ignores those who found the proprietor of the neighbourhood store rude, the service poor or the prices too high. The survival of the neighbourhood store may not be so important to you if you are on welfare, the kids need winter boots and Wal-Mart is having a blowout sale. Slee’s obsession with the politics of Marketthink blinds him to the reality of consumer choice.
Slee also turns his sights on brands, contending that we often do not choose the brand that offers the best value for money. We choose brands for a wide variety of reasons, of which value is only one. Some brands make a statement to the world about our attitudes and values, such as when Harley-Davidson riders (or wannabes) tattoo the logo on their bodies. To understand brands is to understand that people make choices for reasons that may seem illogical, unreasonable or plain stupid.
Zeroing in on fast food, Slee laments that “companies like McDonald’s may be successful even if people don’t like their food all that much … a food environment based on predictable franchise operations may win out over an environment based on independent businesses, even if those independent businesses may be able to provide better value on average.”
But this misses the point. In fast food restaurants, predictability is a virtue. There are many restaurants that offer good value, but many people—especially families—want to know before they pass through the doors that what they are buying will taste good, will be clean and will not cost too much. The golden arches are not there to signal gourmet fare or even value for money, but predictability.
No One Makes You Shop at Wal-Mart is clearly written and, in a highly technical field, Slee does a commendable job of making game theory accessible to the average reader. He debunks conspiracy theories that bad results come from manipulative corporate players, showing instead the aggregate consequences of choices made by individual consumers and corporations.
But he wears his ideology all too blatantly. This book is not a search for truth about human behaviour, but a search for evidence that confirms his existing bias for collective action and regulation. In standing on the shoulders of giants like von Neumann and Nash, Slee chooses not to admire the view but to look downward. What might have been an interesting analysis of human behaviour is reduced to a simplistic diatribe based on half-truths.
Let’s return to our two drivers, racing toward each other on a dusty desert road. Unlike the prisoner’s dilemma, the game of chicken has a happy outcome: one of the two drivers will swerve. Perhaps we would prefer it if they had not engaged in the exercise at all. But they did, and left to their own devices they chose well. Individual choice can be a good thing, too.
David Dunne is an Irish Canadian author whose titles include Design Thinking at Work. He is currently writing a book about the Irish border region.
Related Letters and Responses
Tom Slee Waterloo, Ontario